IACR News
If you have a news item you wish to distribute, they should be sent to the communications secretary. See also the events database for conference announcements.
Here you can see all recent updates to the IACR webpage. These updates are also available:
20 May 2026
Calvin Abou Haidar, Thomas Espitau, Clément Hoffmann, Mehdi Tibouchi
Discrete Gaussian sampling is an important operation at the core of many lattice-based cryptosystems, which presents significant challenges from an implementation standpoint. In particular, it is difficult to protect against side-channel attacks.
Extensive research has gone into the problem of addressing timing side-channel attacks, and as result, constant-time discrete Gaussian sampling is now well-understood. However, few papers so far have attempted to achieve protection against stronger side-channel attacks like correlation power analysis via, e.g., masking, and those that have tend to suffer from underwhelming performance.
Focusing on the case of discrete Gaussians with fixed center and standard deviation, the state-of-the-art approach to applying a masking countermeasure is to start from a constant-time cumulative distribution table-based (CDT-based) sampler, possibly with a search tree twist. Such a CDT-based sampler compares a uniform random value to each element of the CDT of the target distribution. Replacing these comparisons with a masked comparison circuit (typically based on a carry-save adder like Kogge-Stone) yields the desired, albeit costly, countermeasure.
In this paper, we propose a very different approach to masked discrete Gaussian sampling. We start from a new rejection-based discrete Gaussian sampler, obtained by discretizing a sampler for the continuous normal distribution related to an algorithm of Marsaglia (1963). We show that our new sampler can be expressed elegantly in terms of uniform and geometric distributions, in a way that is surprisingly friendly to masking, particularly when using bitslicing. The resulting masked, t-probing secure gadget dramatically outperforms previous work. When applied to NIST candidate signature HAWK, we find it to need less than 5 masked AND gates per generated sample on a 32-bit architecture, and about 20 times fewer than the state-of-the-art, comparison tree-based masked sampler of Eid et al. (TCHES 2026). Furthermore, we show that while Eid et al.'s sampler can be sped up with significant tweaks (bitslicing, faster masked comparisons, etc.), the modified gadget still requires 4 to 5 times as many masked AND gates as our techniques.
Extensive research has gone into the problem of addressing timing side-channel attacks, and as result, constant-time discrete Gaussian sampling is now well-understood. However, few papers so far have attempted to achieve protection against stronger side-channel attacks like correlation power analysis via, e.g., masking, and those that have tend to suffer from underwhelming performance.
Focusing on the case of discrete Gaussians with fixed center and standard deviation, the state-of-the-art approach to applying a masking countermeasure is to start from a constant-time cumulative distribution table-based (CDT-based) sampler, possibly with a search tree twist. Such a CDT-based sampler compares a uniform random value to each element of the CDT of the target distribution. Replacing these comparisons with a masked comparison circuit (typically based on a carry-save adder like Kogge-Stone) yields the desired, albeit costly, countermeasure.
In this paper, we propose a very different approach to masked discrete Gaussian sampling. We start from a new rejection-based discrete Gaussian sampler, obtained by discretizing a sampler for the continuous normal distribution related to an algorithm of Marsaglia (1963). We show that our new sampler can be expressed elegantly in terms of uniform and geometric distributions, in a way that is surprisingly friendly to masking, particularly when using bitslicing. The resulting masked, t-probing secure gadget dramatically outperforms previous work. When applied to NIST candidate signature HAWK, we find it to need less than 5 masked AND gates per generated sample on a 32-bit architecture, and about 20 times fewer than the state-of-the-art, comparison tree-based masked sampler of Eid et al. (TCHES 2026). Furthermore, we show that while Eid et al.'s sampler can be sped up with significant tweaks (bitslicing, faster masked comparisons, etc.), the modified gadget still requires 4 to 5 times as many masked AND gates as our techniques.
Seung-Won Lee, Min-Seo Kim, Ui-Jae Kim, Hui-Ju Kang, Hwa-Jeong Seo
The transition to post-quantum cryptography (PQC) digital signatures poses an unexpected threat to the storage structure of relational databases. At the same security level, the AIMer-192f signature reaches 13,056\,B, which is more than 13 times that of RSA-7680 (960\,B). Storing it inline in MySQL InnoDB causes the B$^+$-Tree fan-out to collapse from the theoretically predicted value of 167 to a measured value of 1. This result experimentally reveals that the off-page storage model in the MySQL official manual has a factor of 167 error in this case. To address this problem, we propose an architecture that combines a split-table schema with a Merkle Tree-based batch signing approach. The proposed architecture ($B=512$) restores the collapsed fan-out to 41, reduces the number of leaf pages by 97\%, and improves insertion throughput by 28.1$\times$. It also reduces the per-document signature storage cost by up to 97.6\%. This study quantifies the limitations of the traditional single-table storage approach in a PQC migration environment and presents a practical mitigation architecture.
Serge Vaudenay
We define a protocol by which we can recognize if a person is the owner of an object. The object can, for instance, be an official document such as a diploma. In our model, the object has an attached RFID chip. The owner is enrolled when the document is created and the chip is attached. Later on, public verifying terminals can verify if a person is the enrolled owner by means of biometric recognition. Hence, the terminal must scan both the chip and the person. As an implementation demonstrator, we use fingervein biometry. Our system can also be used for access control to an online repository to get more information and services related to the object. We require strong security and privacy levels such as: a secure owner recognition and access limited to the legitimate owner holding the right document, the principle of least privilege, and no storage of biometric data at rest. Our solution relies on an inexpensive off-the-shelf RFID chip.
Shaozheng He, Jiongjiong Ren, Shaozhen Chen, Jiaxin Yan, Jianhua Hou
Given that the Walsh spectrum directly determines key cryptographic properties of Boolean functions, the construction of such functions with desired spectral features has been a major research focus for decades. In this study, we first establish a unified framework for a class of specific Boolean function construction problems corresponding to Walsh transform, which we formally define as \textbf{Problem}. To tackle the \textbf{Problem}, we first designed the Iterative Walsh Recovery (IWR) algorithm as a framework, then added Forgetting and Greedy strategies for heuristic optimization to obtain the FG-IWR algorithm, and finally proved a necessary condition for optimization, ultimately proposing the Optimized Iterative Walsh Recovery (OIWR) algorithm. Through rigorous theoretical analysis and experimental validation, our algorithm simultaneously achieves theoretical guarantees, design flexibility, and computational efficiency. For application, we further present a novel construction method for low-weight correlation immune functions using the OIWR algorithm. Experimental results show that our method successfully addresses two fundamental constraints of Mesnager-Su's approach: limited construction capacity and power-of-two weight restrictions.
19 May 2026
Clémence Chevignard, André Schrottenloher, Yixin Shen
Discrete Gaussian Sampling on lattices is a fundamental problem in lattice-based cryptography. It appears both in basic cryptographic primitives such as digital signatures and as an important cryptanalysis building block for solving hard lattice problems. In this paper, we show a quantum algorithm based on the quantum rejection sampling technique whose complexity is asymptotically quadratically faster than its classical counterpart in [Wang \& Ling, IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 2019]. Our sampler outputs a quantum state which can either be measured to get the desired distribution or be used directly as such in other quantum algorithms. By doing so, we derive two versions of quantum dual attacks that improve upon the previous ones in [Pouly \& Shen, EUROCRYPT 2024]. The two versions are incomparable, each having distinct advantages (speed vs memory requirement). The second version is particularly interesting as it requires only polynomial classical and quantum memory, excluding the classical memory used in the preprocessing step of the Discrete Gaussian sampler. Our quantum Discrete Gaussian sampler can also be used to speed up the algorithm for solving the Short Integer Solution problem, in any norm, of [Pouly \& Shen, ePrint 2026/225].
Ramses Fernandez
This paper formalizes the cryptographic core of the FLEX protocol and its enhanced variation FLEX2 . The analysis formalizes a minimal ledger abstraction, capturing Taproot, CSV timelocks, and reorg bounds, and defines ideal functionalities implemented as transaction-DAG and state machines. Main contributions include proving on-chain enforceability, CDS secrecy, soundness, leakage-bounded privacy, and universal composability realization under standard assumptions.
Shingo Kukita, Rei Iseki, Takeshi Namatame, Kohtaro Watanabe
The QC-MDPC McEliece cryptosystem is a promising candidate for post-quantum cryptography, and the decoding performance of the underlying QC-MDPC code directly affects the security of the scheme. Deep unfolding, a framework that unfolds an iterative algorithm into a neural network with trainable weights, has been shown to improve belief propagation (BP) decoding for codes with dense parity-check matrices. However, applying deep unfolding directly to the large QC-MDPC codes used in practice is impractical owing to the computational cost of training. Moreover, in QC-MDPC-based cryptosystems, the parity-check matrix serves as the secret key and must be replaced periodically; key-specific training would therefore need to be repeated at each replacement. We address both issues through zero-shot transfer. We propose weight homogenisation, which constrains the trainable weights to a single scalar per iteration, making them independent of the specific Tanner graph. This enables a decoder trained on a small QC-MDPC code to be applied directly to larger codes. Experiments on QC-MDPC codes with parameters proposed for 80-bit and 128-bit security demonstrate that the proposed method achieves a lower decoding error rate than standard BP.
Yuxuan Wang
In side-channel analysis of ML-KEM (a NIST-standard PQC algorithm), SASCA is a powerful profiling attack. However, obtaining a profiling device strictly matching the target is challenging in practice. To address this, we propose the first profiling-device-free SASCA framework for ML-KEM. The framework first controls the NTT input by choosing ciphertexts and trains a leakage model. Subsequently, leveraging the similarity between NTT and INTT, it uses adversarial unsupervised domain adaptation to fine-tune the model for INTT and recover its secret input. Validated on real embedded devices, the framework achieves effective key recovery using a comparable number of traces to profiling SASCA.
Hanbeom Shin, Sunyeop Kim, Byoungjin Seok, Deukjo Hong, Jaechul Sung, Seokhie Hong, Sangjin Lee, Dongjae Lee
A key-independent secret-key distinguisher identifies structural deviations from an ideal random permutation without discovering any information about the secret key. It is therefore of primary importance for understanding the inherent properties of a block cipher's round function. While numerous key-independent secret-key distinguishers have been proposed for 5- and 6-round AES, none has been proposed for 7-round AES to date. In this paper, we propose the first key-independent secret-key distinguisher for 7-round AES, which exploits solely the structural properties of the round function. We propose the Joint Generalized Zero-Difference Property, where a quartet constructed from related differences satisfies three distinct generalized zero-difference properties simultaneously. By leveraging this joint property, we construct a new 7-round differential characteristic that a right quartet follows with a probability of $2^{-250.4}$, whereas a random permutation satisfies the same conditions with a probability of $2^{-253.4}$. Based on this characteristic, we design a distinguishing attack requiring data, time, and memory complexities of $2^{126.2}$. Our analysis confirms that the proposed distinguisher achieves a success probability of approximately 77.8%. We experimentally verify the joint property using small-scale AES, confirming that the theoretical predictions match the observed results. This work achieves the longest-round key-independent secret-key distinguisher for AES reported to date.
Maastricht, Netherlands, 24 May - 28 May 2027
Event date: 24 May to 28 May 2027
Bruxelles, Belgique, 19 May 2026
Event date: 19 May 2026
Antalya Province, Turkey, 9 October - 10 October 2026
Event date: 9 October to 10 October 2026
Submission deadline: 19 June 2026
Notification: 21 August 2026
Submission deadline: 19 June 2026
Notification: 21 August 2026
18 May 2026
Nicholas Zhao, Cong Ling
In this work, we revisit the dual attack framework proposed by Pouly and Shen, focusing on the lattice Gaussian sampling term that is a significant bottleneck in the overall attack complexity. We show that this sampling step can be quantumly accelerated by combining the lower bound underlying Wang and Ling's analysis of Klein's algorithm with the quantum rejection sampling (QRS) framework proposed by Ozols et al. Specifically, this lower bound gives precisely the pointwise condition required for quantum rejection sampling when given coherent oracle access to a truncated Klein proposal distribution, which yields a quantum procedure for preparing the truncated dual $q$-ary lattice Gaussian with a quadratic reduction in the sampling complexity. The truncation radius is chosen so that the truncated distribution is negligibly close to the full lattice Gaussian in total variation distance. Substituting this sampler into their dual attack framework results in reduced overall attack-cost estimates. Compared with the Pouly and Shen dual attack (no modulus switching), our method reduces the estimated attack cost by $9$, $4$, and $13$ bits for Kyber-512, Kyber-768, and Kyber-1024 respectively.
Shuhe Cao, Xin Wang, Chenxu Wang, Xiao Sui, Sisi Duan
TLA$^+$ (Temporal Logic of Actions) is a formal specification language well-suited for distributed systems. However, writing proper TLA$^+$ scripts requires high domain expertise. When it comes to modeling Byzantine behaviors for Byzantine fault-tolerant consensus protocols, the simulation of malicious behavior is a fundamental challenge: overly simplified modeling misses critical vulnerabilities, and verbose modeling leads to state-space explosion.
In this paper, we present TLAssist, a large language model (LLM)-assisted tool for semi-automated TLA$^+$ generation tailored for Byzantine reliable broadcast (RBC) protocols. We provide a highly structured workflow and domain-specific data format to improve the quality of LLM prompts. Using five RBC protocols as case studies, we have some interesting findings. First, the specification generated by TLAssist outperforms many open-source TLA$^+$ scripts we are aware of, including those written by domain experts. Second, TLAssist can assist domain experts in identifying deep design flaws. Notably, our case study on the (2,3,4)-Optimistic RBC (a CCS'25 distinguished paper) captures a subtle issue that causes the violation of the totality property. Finally, TLAssist is useful for non-experts. Namely, we show that by revising the protocols slightly, the generated error traces effectively show complex corner cases that can facilitate understanding of the design.
In this paper, we present TLAssist, a large language model (LLM)-assisted tool for semi-automated TLA$^+$ generation tailored for Byzantine reliable broadcast (RBC) protocols. We provide a highly structured workflow and domain-specific data format to improve the quality of LLM prompts. Using five RBC protocols as case studies, we have some interesting findings. First, the specification generated by TLAssist outperforms many open-source TLA$^+$ scripts we are aware of, including those written by domain experts. Second, TLAssist can assist domain experts in identifying deep design flaws. Notably, our case study on the (2,3,4)-Optimistic RBC (a CCS'25 distinguished paper) captures a subtle issue that causes the violation of the totality property. Finally, TLAssist is useful for non-experts. Namely, we show that by revising the protocols slightly, the generated error traces effectively show complex corner cases that can facilitate understanding of the design.
David Inyangson, Sahbaaz Ansari, Tushar M. Jois, Rosario Gennaro, Gamze Gursoy, Gabriel Kaptchuk, Moti Yung, Diogo Barradas
Cloud computing has become the standard for large-scale computation, offering elastic scalability and on-demand resources that exceed typical on-premise capabilities. However, many large-scale computations over sensitive data -- such as genome-wide association studies (GWAS) -- face significant barriers to cloud adoption due to privacy concerns and regulatory constraints. While cryptographic primitives like multi-party computation can alleviate these concerns through provable privacy guaranties, their substantial communication and computational overhead can make cloud deployment cost-prohibitive. To address both privacy and cost constraints, we present ThriftyMPC. ThriftyMPC is a framework that leverages spot instances (ephemeral cloud compute at reduced rates) to enable cost-effective, privacy-preserving computation at scale by combining secure multi-party computation with preemption-tolerant execution. We introduce a formal model for multi-party execution under ephemeral compute conditions, demonstrate how ThriftyMPC handles spot instance preemptions while maintaining cryptographic security guaranties, and provide a formal discussion of these guaranties. Our evaluations on realistic GWAS-inspired workloads over the Google Cloud Platform demonstrate robust execution despite spot instance churn, and show significant cost reduction compared to the state-of-the-art multi-party computation framework (MP-SPDZ) run traditionally using on-demand instances. We show that leveraging multi-party computation on spot instances makes privacy-preserving computation economically viable, enabling organizations to harness the cloud for sensitive workloads previously confined to isolated, on-premise deployments.
Gilad Asharov
Threshold ECDSA signing has become a standard building block for securing cryptocurrency assets, with the protocol of Doerner, Kondi, Lee, and shelat (DKLs, IEEE S&P 2024) emerging as a leading solution due to its efficiency and widespread industry adoption.
In this work, we revisit the DKLs protocol to evaluate its concrete security and implementation trade-offs:
* Vector Oblivious Linear Evaluation (VOLE): We identify subtle issues in the underlying OT-based Vector Oblivious Linear Evaluation (VOLE) sub-protocol, showing that original parameter choices must be adjusted to reach intended security levels. To address this, we provide a complete analysis of three VOLE variants offering different trade-offs between bandwidth and round complexity.
* Two-Party Signing: We introduce an optimized two-party signing protocol that shifts the majority of computation and communication to a message- and key-independent preprocessing phase. This results in an exceptionally efficient online phase where each party exchanges only 0.2KB, a roughly 600 times reduction in communication compared to the full protocol, without being susceptible to known ``pre-signature'' attacks.
Our findings consolidate the security of the protocol while providing significant efficiency improvements for practical deployment and standardization.
In this work, we revisit the DKLs protocol to evaluate its concrete security and implementation trade-offs:
* Vector Oblivious Linear Evaluation (VOLE): We identify subtle issues in the underlying OT-based Vector Oblivious Linear Evaluation (VOLE) sub-protocol, showing that original parameter choices must be adjusted to reach intended security levels. To address this, we provide a complete analysis of three VOLE variants offering different trade-offs between bandwidth and round complexity.
* Two-Party Signing: We introduce an optimized two-party signing protocol that shifts the majority of computation and communication to a message- and key-independent preprocessing phase. This results in an exceptionally efficient online phase where each party exchanges only 0.2KB, a roughly 600 times reduction in communication compared to the full protocol, without being susceptible to known ``pre-signature'' attacks.
Our findings consolidate the security of the protocol while providing significant efficiency improvements for practical deployment and standardization.
Xiaopeng Zheng, Hongbo Li, Dingkang Wang
Bootstrapping is the key technique that turns leveled homomorphic encryptionc into fully homomorphic encryption, but it remains a major efficiency bottleneck. Recent work by Z. Liu and Y. Wang (ASIACRYPT 2023) showed how to bootstrap \(N\) LWE ciphertexts with total cost of \(\widetilde{O}(N)\) polynomial multiplications based on the BFV scheme. However, their results achieve \(\widetilde{O}(1)\) complexity only through amortization over large batches, and do not give a genuine non-amortized \(\widetilde{O}(1)\) bound for a single ciphertext.
In this paper, we present a BFV-based functional bootstrapping algorithm for arbitrary functions over large plaintext spaces with total cost of \(\widetilde{O}(1)\) polynomial multiplications for one LWE ciphertext. The same construction also supports small and moderate batches, and processes a batch of \(m\) ciphertexts with total cost \(\widetilde{O}(m)\) in the supported parameter range. The main technical ingredient is a sparse-packing polynomial-evaluation method for BFV ciphertexts, which exploits the duplicated-slot structure to evaluate an arbitrary polynomial on \(m\) encrypted inputs with total cost of \(\widetilde{O}(m)\).
We implement the scheme in Lattigo using the BFV scheme. At 128 bit security and on a single thread, bootstrapping an arbitrary function takes 3.15 seconds for one ciphertext encrypting a 9-bit plaintext and 3.77 seconds for 128 such ciphertexts in one batched invocation. For 16-bit plaintexts, it takes 10.63 seconds for one ciphertext and 18.07 seconds for 16 ciphertexts. These results show that non-amortized single-ciphertext functional bootstrapping, as well as small and moderate batch bootstrapping, can be practical for arbitrary functions over relatively large plaintext spaces.
Nikai Jagganath, Ron Steinfeld, Muhammed F. Esgin, Amin Sakzad, Dongxi Liu, Markku-Juhani O. Saarinen
Threshold ring signatures (TRS) enable a quorum of $T$ users to jointly sign a message while hiding which $T$ of the $N$ ring members participated, supporting privacy-preserving endorsement in ad-hoc settings. That said, many deployments do not need anonymity over every $T$-subset of a ring: when the approval pattern is already public, a structured ring can be sufficient. In this work, we first formalize this setting as a structured threshold ring signature (sTRS) and introduce $\mathsf{LoTRS}$, a lattice-based sTRS that avoids a dedicated leader and keeps interaction to the optimal number of two rounds by separating the threshold signing relation from the anonymity mechanism.
To the best of our knowledge, $\mathsf{LoTRS}$ is the first construction in which a TRS variant is obtained by
combining: (i) an aggregated signing layer: a two-round lattice-based multisignature protocol producing an aggregated signature relation, with (ii) a selection-hiding layer: a $1$-out-of-$N$ proof that hides the chosen ring element supporting that relation.
While it is natural to use a $T$-out-of-$N$ proof to build a TRS, our $\mathsf{LoTRS}$ exploits a $1$-out-of-$N$ proof to significantly improve efficiency.
$\mathsf{LoTRS}$ concretely instantiates the aggregated signing layer using $\mathsf{DualMS}$ (Crypto'23) and the selection-hiding layer arising from Esgin et al.'s lattice-based one-out-of-many proof (IEEE S&P'22).
Our $(T, N\!\cdot\!T)$-$\mathsf{LoTRS}$ construction achieves $\mathsf{polylog}(N, T)$ signature size and outperforms $(T, N)$-TRS schemes significantly. For example, for $N=100$ and $T=50$, our signature size is only $36$ KB, which is $\approx3.5 \times$ smaller than the previously best performing lattice-based scheme $\mathsf{LastRings}$ by Jeon et al (ISC'25). Our Rust reference implementation further supports practicality: for $T=16$ and $N=32$, i.e., structured ring size $T\cdot N = 512$, it produces $25$ KB signatures, with mean signing time $149$ ms and verification time $43$ ms in a release build on a Ryzen AI 9 HX 370 laptop.
Our $(T, N\!\cdot\!T)$-$\mathsf{LoTRS}$ construction achieves $\mathsf{polylog}(N, T)$ signature size and outperforms $(T, N)$-TRS schemes significantly. For example, for $N=100$ and $T=50$, our signature size is only $36$ KB, which is $\approx3.5 \times$ smaller than the previously best performing lattice-based scheme $\mathsf{LastRings}$ by Jeon et al (ISC'25). Our Rust reference implementation further supports practicality: for $T=16$ and $N=32$, i.e., structured ring size $T\cdot N = 512$, it produces $25$ KB signatures, with mean signing time $149$ ms and verification time $43$ ms in a release build on a Ryzen AI 9 HX 370 laptop.
17 May 2026
Won Kim, Changmin Lee, JeongHwan Lee, Alain Passelègue, Damien Stehlé
We study $t$-out-of-$n$ threshold fully homomorphic encryption (ThFHE) based on Shamir secret sharing (SSS) in the asynchronous setting. A central bottleneck for SSS-based ThFHE is that Lagrange reconstruction during distributed decryption can amplify noise, forcing a substantially larger ciphertext modulus to maintain correctness.
In this work, we revisit SSS-based ThFHE and give a rigorous analysis of the correctness and simulation-security constraints that govern parameter choices. We then compare families of Lagrange interpolation points through the lens of these constraints.
Our main contributions are analytic bounds that closely track empirical behavior and significantly reduce the modulus overhead required for distributed decryption. For example, for $n = 512$, our analysis reduces this modulus overhead (in bits) by 30% for $t = n/2$ and by up to 90% for $t$ close to $n$, compared to prior parameterizations.
In this work, we revisit SSS-based ThFHE and give a rigorous analysis of the correctness and simulation-security constraints that govern parameter choices. We then compare families of Lagrange interpolation points through the lens of these constraints.
Our main contributions are analytic bounds that closely track empirical behavior and significantly reduce the modulus overhead required for distributed decryption. For example, for $n = 512$, our analysis reduces this modulus overhead (in bits) by 30% for $t = n/2$ and by up to 90% for $t$ close to $n$, compared to prior parameterizations.
Thai Hung Le
Enhanced Gabidulin Matrix Codes (EGMC), introduced by Aragon, Couvreur, Dyseryn, Gaborit, and Vincotte at Asiacrypt 2024, were designed to hide the algebraic structure of Gabidulin matrix codes while enabling very compact McEliece- and Niederreiter-type encryption schemes, with ciphertexts as small as 65 bytes at the claimed 128-bit security level. Their security relies on the assumption that a masked EGMC code is hard to distinguish from a random matrix code. We show that this enhanced construction leaves enough structure for an equivalent code of the secret key to be recovered. Unlike previous cryptanalysis, our attack combines combinatorial and algebraic techniques to recover a Gabidulin-equivalent compressed code. This code can then be extended to a full-length equivalent secret key in polynomial time. As a result, the attack provides both a distinguisher and a key-recovery attack against the EGMC encryption schemes. The attack breaks all 16 proposed EGMC parameter sets by large margins. For example, for the claimed 128-bit parameter set $(2,17,37,4,0)$, it reduces the security level from 186 bits to 35 bits. In our implementation, the equivalent secret key is recovered in less than 10 minutes.