International Association for Cryptologic Research

International Association
for Cryptologic Research

IACR News

If you have a news item you wish to distribute, they should be sent to the communications secretary. See also the events database for conference announcements.

Here you can see all recent updates to the IACR webpage. These updates are also available:

email icon
via email
RSS symbol icon
via RSS feed

22 December 2025

Jesko Dujmovic, Angelos Pelecanos, Stefano Tessaro
ePrint Report ePrint Report
Over the past two decades, several works have used (almost) $k$-wise independence as a proxy for pseudorandomness in block ciphers, since it guarantees resistance against broad classes of statistical attacks. For example, even the case $k = 2$ already implies security against differential and linear cryptanalysis.

Hoory, Magen, Myers, and Rackoff (ICALP ’04; TCS ’05) formulated an appealing conjecture: if the sequential composition of $T$ independent local randomized permutations is (close to) four-wise independent, then it should also be a pseudorandom permutation. Here, "local" means that each output bit depends on only a constant number of input bits. This conjecture offers a potential strong justification for analyses of block ciphers that establish (almost) $k$-wise independence of this type of constructions.

In this work, we disprove the conjecture in full generality by presenting an explicit local randomized permutation whose sequential composition is four-wise independent, but not a pseudorandom permutation. Our counterexample in fact extends to $k$-wise independence for any constant $k$.
Expand
Jiacheng Gao, Moyang Xie, Yuan Zhang, Sheng Zhong
ePrint Report ePrint Report
In most secure multiparty computation (MPC) scenarios, the data to be processed are much smaller than the underlying field size. The field is typically chosen to be large enough to guarantee security, e.g., a 128-bit prime field for 128-bit security, while the data can be as small as several bits, e.g. $4$ bits for a $16$-category classification task. This size gap can result in significant waste of communication and computation in existing MPC protocols, which often treat data of different ranges indiscriminately.

We introduce UFO$_\mathrm{s}$, an ultra-fast toolkit for multiparty computation (MPC) on small elements. UFO$_\mathrm{s}$ provides highly optimized protocols for three fundamental tasks: one-hot encoding, comparison and digit decomposition. While these protocols are designed specifically for small elements, as a demonstration of their power, we construct a radix sort protocol that sorts large field elements. Our experiments show significant performance improvements over state-of-the-art MPC implementations. In particular, our sorting protocol achieves up to a $58\times$ speedup in the online phase when sorting $2^{16}$ elements among $5$ parties.
Expand
Céline Chevalier, Paul Hermouet, Quoc-Huy Vu
ePrint Report ePrint Report
The emergence of quantum computing has provided new paradigms for cryptography. On the one hand, it poses significant new threats to existing classically cryptographic systems, requiring the community to define new security models that capture what a quantum adversary can do. On the other hand, it gives us new tools to design cryptographic protocols, with weaker assumptions than in the classical world, or even protocols that are impossible classically.

In this survey, we first give an overview of new security definitions for classical cryptography, considering quantum adversaries who can either only use local quantum computation (post-quantum security), or even send quantum messages and in particular have access to oracle in superposition (quantum security). We explore these new notions through the examples of commitments, zero-knowledge proofs, encryption, and signatures. Then, we present what is arguably the most famous application of quantum cryptography: quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols that take advantage of unique properties of quantum mechanics to provide secure communication unconditionally. We also explore cryptography beyond QKD, focusing on unclonable cryptography: a family of cryptographic functionalities, built with quantum states, and designed to be resistant to counterfeit by leveraging the “no-cloning” theorem. We examine in particular quantum money, but also the recent notions of unclonable encryption and copy-protection, including related variants.

By presenting a comprehensive survey of these topics, this paper aims to provide a thorough understanding of the current landscape and future potential of quantum cryptography.
Expand
Marco Baldi, Rahmi El Mechri, Paolo Santini, Riccardo Schiavoni
ePrint Report ePrint Report
The \textit{hull} of a linear code is the intersection between the code and its dual. When the hull is equal to the code (i.e., the code is contained in the dual), the code is called \textit{self-orthogonal} (or \textit{weakly self-dual}); if, moreover, the code is equal to its dual, then we speak of a \textit{self-dual} code. For problems such as the Permutation Equivalence Problem (PEP) and (special instances of) the Lattice Isomorphism Problem (LIP) over $q$-ary lattices, codes with a sufficiently large hull provide hard-to-solve instances. In this paper we describe a technique to compress the representation of a self-orthogonal code. Namely, we propose an efficient compression (and decompression) technique that allows representing the generator matrix of a self-orthogonal code with slightly more than $k(n-k)-\binom{k+1}{2}$ finite field elements. The rationale consists in exploiting the relationships deriving from self-orthogonality to reconstruct part of the generator matrix entries from the others, thus reducing the amount of entries one needs to uniquely represent the code. For instance, for self-dual codes, this almost halves the amount of finite field elements required to represent the code.

We first present a basic version of our algorithm and show that it runs in polynomial time and, moreover, its communication cost asymptotically approaches the lower bound set by Shannon's source coding theorem. Then, we provide an improved version which reduces both the size of the representation and the time complexity, essentially making the representation technique as costly as Gaussian elimination.

%Under plausible heuristic assumptions (which we have verified via intensive numerical simulations), we furthermore show that our encoding technique is asymptotically optimal (in the sense that the amount of required information bits matches with the theoretical lower bound from Shannon's theorem).

As concrete applications, we show that our technique can be used to reduce the public key size in cryptosystems based on PEP such as LESS and SPECK (achieving approximately a 50% reduction in the public key size), as well as in the Updatable Public Key Encryption Scheme recently proposed by Albrecht, Benčina and Lai, which is based on LIP.
Expand
Johannes Blömer, Henrik Bröcher, Volker Krummel, Laurens Porzenheim
ePrint Report ePrint Report
Stateful signatures like the NIST standardized signature schemes LMS and XMSS provide an efficient and mature realization of post-quantum secure signature schemes. They are recommended for long-term use cases like e.g. firmware signing. However, stateful signature schemes require to properly manage a so-called state. In stateful signature schemes like LMS and XMSS, signing keys consist of a set of keys of a one-time signature scheme and it has to be guaranteed that each one-time key is used only once. This is done by updating a state in each signature computation, basically recording which one-time keys have already been used. While this is straightforward in centralized systems, in distributed systems like secure enclaves consisting of e.g. multiple hardware security modules (HSMs) with limited communication keeping a distributed state that at any point in time is consistent among all parties involved presents a challenge. This challenge is not addressed by the current standardization processes. In this paper we present a security model for the distributed key management of post-quantum secure stateful signatures like XMSS and LMS. We also present a simple, efficient, and easy to implement protocol proven secure in this security model, i.e. the protocol guarantees at any point in time a consistent state among the parties in a distributed system, like a distributed security enclave. The security model is defined in the universal composabilty (UC) framework by Ran Canetti by providing an ideal functionality for the distributed key management for stateful signatures. Hence our protocol remains secure even if arbitrarily composed with other instances of the same or other protocols, a necessity for the security of distributed key management protocols. Our main application are security enclaves consisting of HSMs, but the model and the protocol can easily be adapted to other scenarios of distributed key management of stateful signature schemes.
Expand
Ramin Rezvani Gilkolaei, Reza Ebrahimi
ePrint Report ePrint Report
This paper presents a hardware-conscious analysis of the quantum acceleration of the classical 3-round Keccak-256 preimage attack using Grover’s Algorithm. While the theo- retical quantum speed-up from T cl ≈ 2 ^57.8 (classical) to T qu ≈ 2 ^28.9 (quantum) is mathe- matically sound, the practical implementation overhead is so extreme that attacks remain wholly infeasible in both resource and runtime dimensions. Using Qiskit-based circuit synthesis, we derive that a 3-round Keccak quantum oracle requires: • 9,600 Toffoli gates (with uncomputation for reversibility) • 3,200 logical qubits (1,600 state + 1,600 auxiliary) • 7.47 × 10 13 total 2-qubit gates (full Grover search) • 3.2 million physical qubits (with quantum error correction) — PROHIBITIVE • 0.12 years (43 days) to 2,365+ years execution time, depending on machine assumptions These barriers—particularly the physical qubit requirements, circuit depth, and error accumulation—render the quantum attack infeasible for any foreseeable quantum computer. Consequently, SHA-3 security is not threatened by quantum computers for preimage attacks. We emphasize the critical importance of hardware-aware complexity analysis in quantum cryptanalysis: the elegant asymptotic theory of Grover’s Algorithm hides an engineering overhead so prohibitive that the quantum approach becomes infeasible from both resource and implementation perspectives.
Expand

21 December 2025

Election Election
The 2025 election was held to fill three director positions and four office positions. 786 votes have been cast. The results are below, with elected candidates marked in bold:

President:
Allison Bishop: 706

Vice-President:
Britta Hale: 270
François-Xavier Standaert: 336
Mayank Varia: 113

Treasurer:
Brian LaMacchia: 727

Secretary:
Benjamin Wesolowski: 720

Directors:
Shai Halevi: 369
Nadim Kobeissi: 250
Bart Preneel: 470
Adeline Roux-Langlois : 313
Peter Schwabe: 488

Modification to bylaws: :
Yes: 724, No: 43

Election verification data can be found at https://vote.heliosvoting.org/helios/elections/2a7cc106-c58e-11f0-9abe-5682e467d057/view#.

The election committee congratulates all elected members and thanks all candidates for their contributions to the IACR and willingness to serve.
Expand

20 December 2025

Brussels, Belgium, 30 January 2026
Event Calendar Event Calendar
Event date: 30 January 2026
Expand
King's College London
Job Posting Job Posting

We are inviting applications for a PhD studentship in the cryptography lab at King's College London.

The PhD position is focused on the provable security analysis of real-world cryptographic protocols and advanced functionalities. The PhD could, for example, analyse existing secure messaging protocols and functionality that has not undergone formal analysis (LINE secure messaging), evaluate the formal security properties of cryptographic protocols post-quantum transitions (KEM-TLS) or modelling and designing new cryptographic protocols or primitives.

We seek applicants with a strong background in mathematics and/or computer science, preferably with some background in cryptography.

Application process

Applicants are encouraged to contact Dr Benjamin Dowling ([email protected]) and Prof Martin Albrecht ([email protected]) to discuss the position informally before applying.

Formal Application

To be considered for the position, candidates must apply through the King’s Apply online application system. Full details are available on the FindaPhD advertisement 192021.

References
  • King's Cryptographers: https://cryptographers.kcl.ac.uk/people/
  • Social Foundations of Cryptography: https://social-foundations-of-cryptography.gitlab.io/
  • Benjamin Dowling: https://benjamindowling.com/
  • Martin Albrecht: https://malb.io/

Closing date for applications:

Contact: Benjamin Dowling ([email protected])

More information: https://www.findaphd.com/phds/project/analysing-cryptography-in-the-wild/?p192021

Expand
National Research Council Canada
Job Posting Job Posting
We are looking for a Research Officer, Applied Cryptography to join our Cryptography and Quantum Computing team, and to support NRC’s Digital Technologies Research Centre (NRC-DT). The Research Officer, Applied Cryptography would be someone who shares our core values of Integrity, Excellence, Respect and Creativity. Our Cryptography and Quantum Computing team conducts research on quantum/post-quantum cryptography, privacy-preserving computing, and quantum computing. The primary responsibility of the researcher in this position is to support the goals of NRC and the activities of the Digital Technologies Research Centre in conducting research of international calibre in applied post-quantum cryptography and other related topics. The researcher will work in a team environment with other researchers and technical experts in world-class facilities. The researcher will be called on to participate in international evaluations or demonstrations of the team’s applied technologies. Key responsibilities: • Conduct cutting-edge research in applied post-quantum cryptography, collaborating with fellow researchers. • Lead the design, implementation, and evaluation of innovative quantum-safe cryptographic algorithms and protocols. • Lead the development of a post-quantum cryptography lab, fostering collaboration with industry, academia, and government stakeholders. • Write and review project proposals; and lead projects to drive impactful research initiatives in post-quantum cryptography.

Closing date for applications:

Contact: Hiring Services

More information: https://recruitment-recrutement.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/job/Waterloo-Research-Officer%2C-Applied-Cryptography-ON/598268317/

Expand

19 December 2025

Yueming Li, Long Chen, Qianwen Gao, Zhenfeng Zhang
ePrint Report ePrint Report
The Authentication and Key Management for Applications (AKMA) system represents a recently developed protocol established by 3GPP, which is anticipated to become a pivotal component of the 5G standards. AKMA enables application service providers to delegate user authentication processes to mobile network operators, thereby eliminating the need for these providers to store and manage authentication-related data themselves. This delegation enhances the efficiency of authentication procedures but simultaneously introduces certain security and privacy challenges that warrant thorough analysis and mitigation.

The 5G AKMA service is facilitated by the AKMA Anchor Function (AAnF), which may operate outside the boundaries of the 5G core network. A compromise of the AAnF could potentially allow malicious actors to exploit vulnerabilities, enabling them to monitor user login activities or gain unauthorized access to sensitive communication content. Furthermore, the exposure of the Subscription Permanent Identifier (SUPI) to external Application Functions poses substantial privacy risks, as the SUPI could be utilized to correlate a user's real-world identity with their online activities, thereby undermining user privacy.

To mitigate these vulnerabilities, we propose a novel protocol named E2E-AKMA, which facilitates the establishment of a session key between the User Equipment (UE) and the Application Function (AF) with end-to-end security, even in scenarios where the AAnF has been compromised. Furthermore, the protocol ensures that no entity, aside from the 5G core network, can link account activities to the user's actual identity. This architecture preserves the advantages of the existing AKMA scheme, such as eliminating the need for complex dynamic secret data management and avoiding reliance on specialized hardware (apart from standard SIM cards). Experimental evaluations reveal that the E2E-AKMA framework incurs an overhead of approximately 9.4\% in comparison to the original 5G AKMA scheme, which indicates its potential efficiency and practicality for deployment.
Expand

18 December 2025

Andrés Fábrega, Julia Len, Thomas Ristenpart, Gregory Rubin
ePrint Report ePrint Report
We study the problem of random-access authenticated encryption. In this setting, one wishes to encrypt (resp., decrypt) a large payload in an online matter, i.e., using a limited amount of memory, while allowing for the processing of plaintext (resp., ciphertext) segments to be in a random order. Prior work has studied online AE for in-order (streaming) encryption and decryption, and later work added additional constraints to support random access decryption. The result is complicated notions that are not built from the start to account for random access.

We thus provide a new, clean-state treatment to the random-access setting. We introduce random-access authenticated encryption (raAE) schemes, which captures AEAD that provides random-access encryption and decryption. We introduce formal security definitions for raAE schemes that cover confidentiality, integrity, and commitment. We prove relationships with existing notions, showing that our simpler treatment does not sacrifice achievable security. Our implications also result in the first treatment of commitment security for online AEAD as well, an increasingly important security goal for AEAD.

We then exercise our formalization with a practice-motivated case study: FIPS-compliant raAE. We introduce an raAE scheme called FLOE (Fast Lightweight Online Encryption) that is FIPS compliant, compatible with existing AES-GCM APIs that mandate random nonces, and yet can provide secure, random-access, committing encryption of orders of magnitude more data than naive approaches that utilize AES-GCM. FLOE was designed in close collaboration with leading cloud data platform Snowflake, where it will soon be used in production to protect sensitive data.
Expand
YanJin Tan, JunTao Gao, XueLian Li
ePrint Report ePrint Report
The Sum of Even-Mansour (SoEM) construction was proposed by Chen et al. at Crypto 2019. This construction implements a pseudorandom permutation via the modular addition of two independent Even-Mansour structures and can spawn multiple variants by altering the number of permutations or keys. It has become the design basis for some symmetric schemes, such as the nonce-based encryption scheme CENCPP* and the nonce-based message authentication code scheme nEHTm. This paper provides a proof of the quantum security of the SoEM21 construction under the Q1 model: when an attacker has quantum access to the random permutations but only classical access to the keyed construction, the SoEM21 construction ensures security of up to \(n/3\) bits. This exactly matches the complexity \(O(2^{n/3})\) of the quantum key recovery attack in the Q1 model recently proposed by Li et al., thus establishing a tight bound.
Expand
Jayalaxmi H, H M Brunda, Sumith Subraya Nayak, Sathya M, Anirudh S Hegde
ePrint Report ePrint Report
The advent of large-scale quantum computers poses a fundamental threat to widely deployed public-key cryptographic schemes such as RSA and elliptic curve digital signatures. In response, the National Institute of Standards and Technology has standardized several post-quantum cryptographic algorithms, including the Stateless Hash-Based Digital Signature Algorithm (SLH-DSA) specified in FIPS 205. While SLH-DSA offers strong, conservative security guarantees based solely on cryptographic hash functions, its practical adoption depends on a clear understanding of its hardware cost and performance characteristics relative to classical standards.

This paper presents a unified hardware benchmarking study of SLH-DSA against RSA, DSA, ECDSA, and EdDSA. All algorithms are implemented at the register-transfer level in Verilog HDL and synthesized on the same Xilinx Artix-7 FPGA platform to ensure a fair comparison. The evaluation focuses on key hardware metrics, including logic utilization, memory usage, DSP consumption, operational latency, maximum clock frequency, and throughput for key generation, signing, and verification.

The results demonstrate that SLH-DSA is logic- and memory-intensive, with significantly higher signing latency and larger signature sizes compared to classical schemes. However, its verification performance is highly competitive, and its public key size remains extremely small. In contrast, classical schemes are primarily arithmetic-bound and rely heavily on DSP resources. The findings highlight that SLH-DSA represents a viable post-quantum solution for applications prioritizing long-term security assurance and efficient verification, such as firmware authentication and digital archiving, despite its higher signing cost.
Expand
Yimeng Sun, Shiyao Chen, Guowei Liu, Meiqin Wang, Chao Niu
ePrint Report ePrint Report
The growth of advanced cryptographic applications has driven the development of arithmetization-oriented (AO) ciphers over large finite fields, which are designed to minimize multiplicative complexity. However, this design advantage of AO ciphers could also serve as an attack vector. For instance, the \textsf{AIM} one-way function in the post-quantum signature \AIMer proposed at CCS 2023 has been broken by several works soon after its publication. The designers then promptly developed secure patches and proposed an enhanced version, \textsf{AIM2}, which was updated to the latest version of \AIMer that has been selected as one of the winners of the Korean PQC Competition in early 2025.

In this paper, we focus on the algebraic security of AIM2 over $\mathbb{F}_{2^n}$. First, we introduce a resultant-minimized model that reduces eliminations by using a non-$k$ based substitution strategy and linearized-polynomial decomposition, achieving an attack time complexity of $2^{188.76}$ ($2^{195.05}$) primitive calls of \textsf{AIM2-III} when $\omega=2$ ($\omega=2.373$), indicating that the designers have been over-optimistic in the evaluation of their security margin; Second, we propose a subfield reduction technique for the case that exponents approach subfield extension sizes, equation degrees collapse sharply, \textit{e.g.,} the exponent $e_2=141\mapsto 13$ in \textsf{AIM2-V} when considering the subfield $\mathbb{F}_{2^{128}}$. This can lower the algebraic attack complexity to $2^{295.97}$ primitive calls at $\omega=2$, which improves upon designers' estimated bound of Gr\"{o}bner basis attack by about $2^{100}$. Besides, based on our attack methods, we have identified some weak parameter choices, which could provide concrete design guidance for \textsf{AIM2} construction, especially for the exponent of its Mersenne S-box. Finally, to address the potential vulnerabilities, we further propose \textsf{AIM2-patch} with a simple secure patch on \textsf{AIM2}, which can prevent key elimination, neutralize linearized-polynomial decomposition, and raise algebraic attack complexity, while incurring negligible overheads in \AIMer scheme.
Expand
Linhan Yang, Jingwei Chen, Wangchen Dai, Shuai Wang, Wenyuan Wu, Yong Feng
ePrint Report ePrint Report
Privacy-preserving Transformer inference (PPTI) is essential for deploying large language models (LLMs) such as BERT and LLaMA in sensitive domains. In these models, the attention mechanism is both the main source of expressiveness and the dominant performance bottleneck under fully homomorphic encryption (FHE), due to large ciphertext matrix multiplications and the softmax nonlinearity. This paper presents Arion, a non-interactive FHE-based PPTI protocol that specifically optimizes the computation of encrypted attention. First, for the three consecutive ciphertext matrix multiplications in multi-head attention, we introduce the double Baby-Step Giant-Step algorithm, which significantly reduces the number of ciphertext rotations. On BERT-Base, Arion achieves an 82.5% reduction in rotations over the state-of-the-art PPTI protocol MOAI (2025), corresponding to a 5.7x reduction in rotation cost. Second, we propose a linear–nonlinear fusion technique tailored to the softmax evaluation in attention. By decomposing softmax into shift-by-maximum, exponentiation, and reciprocal sub-steps and fusing them with the surrounding encrypted matrix operations, Arion enables efficient attention evaluation while remaining compatible with diverse ciphertext packing formats. We implement Arion using Lattigo and first evaluate attention kernels on popular LLMs including BERT-Tiny, BERT-Base, and LLaMA, confirming the practicality and scalability of the proposed optimizations for encrypted attention computation. For end-to-end applications, on classification tasks for several benchmark datasets, Arion attains accuracy comparable to plaintext inference and yields up to 2.5x end-to-end speedups over MOAI for BERT-Base.
Expand
Xuelian Cao, Zheng Yang, Daniel Reijsbergen, Jianting Ning, Junming Ke, Zhiqiang Ma, Jianying Zhou
ePrint Report ePrint Report
Group signatures allow a group member to sign messages on behalf of the group while preserving the signer’s anonymity, making them invaluable for privacy-sensitive applications. As quantum computing advances, post-quantum security in group signatures becomes essential. Symmetric primitives (SP) offer a promising pathway due to their simplicity, efficiency, and well-understood security foundations. In this paper, we introduce the first \textit{forward-secure dynamic group signature} (FSDGS) framework relying solely on SP. We begin with \textit{hierarchical hypertree group signatures} (HHGS), a basic scheme that securely organizes keys of one-time signatures (OTS) in a hypertree using puncturable pseudorandom functions to enable on-demand key generation and forward security, dynamic enrollment, and which provides resilience against attacks that exploit registration patterns by obfuscating the assignment and usage of keys. We then extend this foundation to HHGS^+, which orchestrates multiple HHGS instances in a generic way, significantly extending the total signing capacity to $O(2^{60})$, which outperforms HHGS's closest competitors while keeping signatures below 8 kilobytes. We prove the security of both schemes in the standard model. Our results outline a practical SP-driven pathway toward post-quantum-secure group signatures suitable for resource-constrained client devices.
Expand
Sanjay Deshpande, Patrick Longa, Jakub Szefer
ePrint Report ePrint Report
FrodoKEM, a conservative post-quantum key encapsulation mechanism based on the plain Learning with Errors (LWE) problem, has been recommended for use by several government cybersecurity agencies and is currently undergoing standardization by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO). Despite its robust security guarantees, FrodoKEM's performance remains one of the main challenges to its widespread adoption. This work addresses this concern by presenting a fully standard-compliant, high-performance hardware implementation of FrodoKEM targeting both FPGA and ASIC platforms. The design introduces a scalable parallelization architecture that supports run-time configurability across all twelve parameter sets, covering three security levels (L1, L3, L5), two PRNG variants (SHAKE-based and AES-based), and both standard and ephemeral modes, alongside synthesis-time tunability through a configurable performance parameter to balance throughput and resource utilization. For security level L1 on Xilinx Ultrascale+ FPGA, the implementation achieves 3,164, 2,846, and 2,614 operations per second for key generation, encapsulation, and decapsulation, respectively, representing the fastest standard-compliant performance reported to date while consuming only 27.8K LUTs, 64 DSPs, and 8.1K flip-flops. These results significantly outperform all prior specification-compliant implementations and even surpass non-compliant designs that sacrifice specification adherence for speed. Furthermore, we present the first ASIC evaluation of FrodoKEM using the NANGATE45 45 nm technology library, achieving 7,194, 6,471, and 5,943 operations per second for key generation, encapsulation, and decapsulation, respectively, with logic area of 0.235 mm$^2$. The ASIC implementation exhibits favorable sub-linear area scaling and competitive energy efficiency across different performance parameter configurations, establishing a baseline for future comparative studies. The results validate FrodoKEM's practical viability for deployment in high-throughput, resource-constrained, and power-sensitive cryptographic applications, demonstrating that conservative post-quantum security can be achieved without compromising performance.
Expand
Wojciech Ciszewski, Stefan Dziembowski, Tomasz Lizurej, Marcin Mielniczuk
ePrint Report ePrint Report
The concept of knowledge has been central in cryptography, especially within cryptographic proof systems. Traditionally, research in this area considers an abstract \emph{prover} defending a claim that it knows a message $M$. Recently, a stronger concept—termed ``individual'' (Dziembowski et al., CRYPTO'23) or ``complete'' (Kelkar et al., CCS'24) knowledge—has emerged. This notion ensures the prover physically stores $M$ on a machine that it controls. As we argue in the paper, this concept also appears in earlier work on ``non-outsourceable puzzles'' (Miller et al., CCS'15), which implicitly assumes that performing quickly complex computation on a string $M$ implies storing it on a single machine.

In this line of work, the authors typically rely on the algorithms whose computation requires a massive number of queries to a hash function $H$. This paper highlights a subtle issue in the modeling used in some of these papers, more concretely, the assumption that H can be modeled as an atomic random oracle on long messages. Unfortunately, this does not correspond well to how the hash functions are constructed in practice. For example, the real-world hash functions (e.g., Merkle-Damgard or sponge-based) allow partial evaluation on long inputs, violating this assumption. Another example is the hashing used in Bitcoin mining, which permits similar precomputation. This undermines some protocols relying on individual knowledge. We demonstrate practical attacks against Miller et al.'s and Kelkar et al.'s schemes based on this observation, and discuss secure alternatives. Our alternative constructions, which are modifications of the original ones, avoid reliance on the random oracle behavior of hash functions on long messages. In the full version of this paper, we will provide their formal security analysis in the individual cryptography model of Dziembowski et al. (CRYPTO'23).
Expand
Benedikt Auerbach, Yevgeniy Dodis, Daniel Jost, Shuichi Katsumata, Rolfe Schmidt
ePrint Report ePrint Report
Transitioning existing classical two-party secure messaging protocols to post-quantum protocols has been an active movement in practice in recent years: Apple’s PQ3 protocol and the recent Triple Ratchet protocol being investigated by the Signal team with academics (Dodis et al. Eurocrypt’25). However, due to the large communication overhead of post-quantum primitives, numerous design choices non-existent in the classical setting are being explored, rendering comparison of secure messaging protocols difficult, if not impossible.

In this work, we thus propose a new pragmatic metric to measure how secure a messaging protocol is given a particular communication pattern, enabling a concrete methodology to compare secure messaging protocols. We uncover that there can be no “optimal” protocol, as different protocols are often incomparable with the respect to worst-case (adversarial) messaging behaviors, especially when faced with real-world bandwidth constraints. We develop a comprehensive framework to experimentally compare various messaging protocols under given bandwidth limits and messaging behaviors. Finally, we apply our framework to compare several new and old messaging protocols. Independently, we also uncover untapped optimizations which we call opportunistic sending, leading to better post-quantum messaging protocols. To capture these optimizations, we further propose sparse continuous key agreement as a fundamental building block for secure messaging protocols, which could be of independent interest.
Expand
◄ Previous Next ►